We've keep a guest book at the Catskill Rose since we opened in 1987.
Here are a few of those comments:

wonderful atmosphere.   Excellent! 
Just Divine!   Well Done. PERFECTION.
Great Food! Great Place! Best Dessrts.
My palate swam in ectasy.
Simply Superb. Sublime
WOW YUM
Our Favorite Classy Joint.
The duck is to die for..
Now we're cookin' baby!
Perfect meal as usual.

Of coarse our customers are wonderful and may be partial;
we are also aclaimed by  frommers, fodors, zagat, mobil travel guide, travel & leisure, ny magazine 
Come in and taste for yourself!